Fight the power, get 10 days forced vacation

Jim | Florida | Saturday, January 31st, 2004

Rebel flag petition sparks war of words
Update1: Girl Suspended After Protest Over Rebel Flag
Update2: Flag protester’s suspension will be reduced

Last updated 31 January

Krista Abram’s moved from Pittsburgh to Tarpon Springs (Fla) and was shocked at the casual usage of the Confederate flag. This is understandable. Up north it just isn’t used. It’s considered a symbol of racism, period. Down south it is commonly used to express southern pride. Unfortunately it is a tarnished symbol and no matter how we dislike the fact, it does mean racism to many people. Does that mean I agree with Krista that the flag should be banned? No, but it does mean that she has a legitimate grievance.

Update1: Some of the slogans that accompanied the flag t-shirts were of an obviously racist slant. Example: “If I had known this, I would have picked my own cotton.”

So on Tuesday at lunch she and her brother went around asking people to sign a petition “in favor of a ban on symbols that could be interpreted as discriminatory”. Sounds reasonable to me. Proactive, peaceful, fairly effective (94 signatures). It wasn’t reasonable to the school though. They sent her home and gave her a 10 day suspension. Seems she broke a rule requiring that student petitions be approved by the principal.

Now two things bother me here. First, 10 days is a massive suspension. Two entire weeks out of school for failure to consult the principal before passing around a petition during her free time. This is a monstrous abuse of power and the punishment goes far beyond what the infraction deserves.

A single mother, [Paula] Lopez said her daughter was never given a hearing as required by school codes and she received written notification about the suspension only Thursday.

A ten day suspension without a hearing. That’s unbelievable abuse. The school failed to abide by their own codes and levied a huge penalty on Krista for breaking one. That smacks of hypocrisy and the “Above the rules” attitude present in too many institutions.

The second thing that bothers me is the censorship powers of the principal. Would he have allowed this petition to be circulated if he had been approached properly? The crushing 10 day sentence tends to indicate that this would not have been the case and was perhaps why Krista didn’t submit it.

Update2:

Pinellas County school administrators expect that Krista Abram’s 10-day suspension from Tarpon Springs High School will be reduced, superintendent Howard Hinesley said Friday.

On Friday, Tarpon Springs High principal Dennis Duda called Abram’s mother to schedule a meeting to discuss the suspension.

Hinesley said he didn’t talk to Duda and said the decision of whether to reduce the suspension and by how much would rest with the principal.

Hinesley said he wasn’t second-guessing how the matter was handled because “I wasn’t there.” But he noted that on a large campus “things can get out of hand really quick” when students are not following directions and not going to class.

Asked what he thought of wearing clothing emblazoned with the Confederate flag, Hinesley said, “Personally, I don’t think a T-shirt like that should be worn. But it doesn’t matter what I think. There are lots of things that people wear that I don’t like.”

He elaborated, saying, “what my personal opinion is or other people’s personal opinions are is irrelevant unless it gets to the point where you can’t manage the school . . . and it rests with the principal to make that determination.”

16 Comments

Leave a comment

RSS feed for comments on this post.